Book Reviews #1
- 2001
The Niagara Gorge
Belt Line: A Pictorial Album
Edited by Gordon J.
Thompson - Niagara Frontier Chapter, NRHS, 21 Francis Street,
Middleport, N.Y. 14105
Softcover, 8 1/2"
X 11'', 68pp., 2000. $14.95 (plus $2.00 shipping).
One of the continent's
more spectacular wonders is the great cataract of the Niagara
River which flows 35 miles between Lake Erie and Lake Ontario.
The river drops 326 feet during its journey, especially in nine
miles of rapids and waterfalls. The water drops 167 feet at the
Canadian Falls and 193 feet over the American Falls, providing
a sight which has lured visitors and tourists from the early days
of the republic. The expanding railroad network made the falls
accessible to tourists in the nineteenth century, but not until
the electric trolley was it possible to travel through the gorge
and witness the watery display in all its power and wonder.The
Niagara Gorge Belt Line, which provided a continuous circular
tour on both sides of the river, consisted of several companies
which were eventually operated by the International Railway Company.
Service began in 1893 over a line along the high escarpment on
the Canadian side of the river. Only three years later, another
company constructed a line on the American side. through the gorge
at water level. By 1899, bridges on each end linked the twin cities
of Niagara Falls, N.Y. and Niagara Falls Ontario, Lewiston, N.Y.
and Queenston, Ontario, providing a loop route of almost 19 miles,
which was marketed as the Niagara Gorge Belt Line. Although highly
successful, especially in the summer season, the Gorge Route was
expensive to maintain. Service ended in 1932 on the Canadian side
and in 1935 on the remainder of the line, as the International
Railway had become increasingly disenchanted with its trolley
lines under pressure of the Depression.
This book presents
a fascinating pictorial account of the Belt Line service. Over
100 clearly reproduced photographs, generally one or two per page,
with extensive informative captions, carry the reader vicariously
along the roaring Niagara River. The photos are organized topically,
under such headings as 'Getting There' (rail and water connecting
services), 'Terminals,' 'the Canadian Scenic Route,' 'the Lewiston-Queenston
Bridge,' and 'the Great Gorge Route.' There are glimpses of special
events, such as President William McKinley's visit on September
6, 1901, the same day he was shot, and the Prince of Wales' visit
in 1927. Rosters, accompanied by illustrations, show the wide
variety of cars employed, including open cars, private cars and
work equipment, virtually all built by Brill or its subsidiaries.
There are three maps, including an outstanding color reproduction
of a 1932 panoramic brochure, which is a centerpiece foldout.
An epilogue recounts developments since 1935 and notes the remaining
traces of the route. All told, this is a well-done, interesting
effort, which recreates what must have been a notable and awe-inspiring
trolley journey. Reasonably priced, it is highly recommended.
Review by : J.N.J.H.
Trains and Trolleys
- Vol. II
Authored by Edgar T.
Mead - Soo Nipi Publications, P.O. Box 18, Sunapee, N.H. 03782.
Softcover 7" x 6",
approximately 100 pages, $25.
This book is another
volume of black-and-white photographs taken by the author from
the mid-1930s through 1993. Mead, who recently passed away, was
an NRHS member and published several other books; he also was
involved with the original Steamtown in Bellow Falls, Vt. None
of the pictures has been previously published, and in an accompanying
letter the author described the book as a portfolio of "rare bird"
photographs. Approximately 80 percent are trains (mostly steam
engines) and the rest are trolleys. There is no index or even
page numbers. The photographs seem to be loosely grouped on a
geographical basis. Most of the pictures were taken in foreign
countries including France, Ireland, Wales, India and Cuba (before
Castro). Most of the pictures are crisp and clear roster shots
with a brief commentary as to the date and location. I was taken
by the variety of locations, and was particularly fascinated by
the picture of a 40-inch-gauge steam railroad that operated between
a mine and breaker near Tamaqua, Pa. in the 1940s. However, given
that one picture was erroneously described as "Amtrak meets Conrail
in 1970", I have to wonder about the accuracy of some of the other
descriptions.
Reviewed by: Kevin
Feeney
DENVER AND RIO GRANDE
WESTERN - SUPERPOWER RAILROAD OF THE ROCKIES
Authored by Robert
A. LeMassena - TLC Publishing, 1387 Winding Creek Lane, Lynchburg,
Va. 24503-3776.
Hardcover, 8-1/2"
x 11", 104 pp. 1999. $28.95 (plus $4.00 shipping and handling).
Author LeMassena enjoys
a well-deserved reputation for his knowledge of steam locomotives
and locomotion and ability to explain them. This book applies
his knowledge to a railroad that has become a favorite of railfans
and rail historians to a degree out of proportion to its size:
the Rio Grande. The term 'superpower' in the title does not apply
to the characteristics espoused by Lima Locomotive Works in developing
a 'modern' steam locomotive, but simply the relative size of the
motive power acquired by the Rio Grande as early as 1910. The
well-illustrated text begins with an introduction to the motive
power of the railroad up to 1910, and continues chronologically
through the end of the steam era. Attention is paid only to standard-gauge
power, so the narrow-gauge locomotives that lived well past the
1956 death of standard- gauge steam are not considered and only
briefly alluded to. Text is largely descriptive, not technical
and detailed. End-of-chapter tables give measurements of the power
described in the chapters. Photographic captions lend additional
description. The book's last chapter, one of its longest, is dedicated
to the story of the boiler explosion of 4-6+6-4 No. 3703 on October
19, 1952. Oddly, most of the accompanying photographs do not depict
the locomotive (except one after the explosion), or even others
of its class. In summary, this book is a good look at the larger
power acquired by the road, with supporting photography. All illustrations
are black-and-white, save for the last 15 pages and the hard cover.
Reviewed by: R. G.
P.
L&N COLOR GUIDE
TO FREIGHT AND PASSENGER EQUIPMENT, VOLUME 1
Authored by Steven
D. Johnson - Morning Sun Books, Inc., 9 Pheasant Lane, Scotch
Plains, N.J., 07076.
Hardcover, 8-1/2" x
11", 128 pp., 2000. $54.95 (plus $3.50 shipping).
This book is another
in a series of color guides, largely for the benefit of the modeler.
These also serve to show the rest of us just how much variety
can exist within what appears to be a standardized set of cars.
And so it is with this volume, which covers boxcars, flatcars,
gondolas and open and covered hoppers. Volume 2 will treat piggyback
and vehicle cars and non-revenue and passenger equipment. Organization
within each group of cars is chronological by build or rebuild
dates, since L&N didn't have a car classification system, and
its numbering systems were equally disorganized. Even rebuilding
groups of cars would sometimes place cars from several former
series in one, and vice versa. Coverage is through the color film
era up to and including the Family Lines paint when L&N was still
applied as reporting marks. Johnson appears to do an excellent
job following the various build and rebuild dates, and works with
conflicting information from different "official" sources. Captions
are particularly enlightening in describing the cars pictured.What
is particularly striking to this reviewer is what variations there
can be in paint jobs for a group of supposedly similar cars. How
large is the lettering? Italic or not? Is the name spelled out?
Any slogans ('Old Reliable' until 1956, then 'Dixie Line')? Color
of body? Color of lettering? Pool markings? Labels for restraining
devices, such as "DF")? The list goes on, and the number of possible
combinations seems inexhaustible. In addition, there are the partial
paint jobs after merger, particularly after the NC&StL was merged
in 1956 (less so for C&EI and Monon). In all, true diversity exists
here. Fans of the L&N and modelers will enjoy this volume.
Reviewer: R.G.P.
THE LOUISVILLE &
NASHVILLE RAILROAD, 1850-1963
Authored by Kincaid
A. Herr - University Press of Kentucky, 663 South Limestone Street,
Lexington, Ky. 40508-4008.
Hardcover, 7" x 10",
416 pp., 2000. $35.00.
Anyone knowledgeable
about the L&N will be familiar with this book. It began in l939
as an extended series of articles in the L&N Magazine, written
by longtime Staff Writer Kincaid A. Kerr. First published as a
book in 1943, it has proved popular enough to warrant several
editions and printings. This volume reprints the last revision,
which came out in 1964. Written in a lucid narrative style, the
author presents what might best be called a corporate history.
It focuses not only on the construction and expansion of the railroad
during the early years, but also covers the Civil War era and
the late 19th Century, before fixing on the "modern" era when
the railroad developed into a major American carrier, operating
such passenger trains as Pan-American, and made the transition
from steam to diesel. Company presidents are generally presented
in a positive light.
More than anything,
however, the book presents a detailed account of the creation,
expansion and operation of the railroad.A few things might bother
some fans. Since it is a reprint, it contains nothing after 1964
aside from a short forward by Lyle Key, CSX Regional Vice President.
The photos, although very interesting, are somewhat lacking in
quality of reproduction. Finally, the index is insufficient. Nonetheless,
L&N fans will want a copy as will the general enthusiast who is
interested in a noncritical but interesting read.
Reviewed by: Bob Trennert
A TICKET TO RIDE
THE NARROW GAUGE
Written by Herbert
Danneman - Colorado Railroad Museum, P. O. Box 10, Golden, Colo.
80402.
Hardcover, 8-1/2" x
11", 272 pp., 2000. $49.95 (plus $3.75 shipping and handling).
The subtitle "A chronological
history of Denver & Rio Grande narrow-gauge passenger trains and
their equipment 1871-1981" pretty much says it all. The chapters
are completely chronological, and the subheadings within chapters
are the individual years. Each year (after the early years about
building the lines and establishing the original service) includes
changes to the service and to the roster of passenger locomotives
and passenger-related rolling stock. Pictures and reproductions
of timetables punctuate the text repeatedly, and add much to its
enjoyment.The attention to "narrow gauge" and "passenger" is almost
slavish; although K-36 and K-37 locomotives often pulled passenger
trains, they are only mentioned in passing. Once a passenger car
is converted for other use, its history is not mentioned. And
once a passenger train is converted from narrow to standard gauge
(first from Denver to Salida, later Grand Junction to Utah and
other lines as well), we know nothing more of service on those
lines. Due to the attention to detail, the reading drags at times;
this is not a novel to be read cover to cover in one sitting.
On the other hand, this is a thoroughly- researched volume, and
despite all the books on the narrow-gauge railroads of Colorado,
much of the information here has never been presented, and gathering
it together in a single volume makes it a worthy member of the
Colorado Rail Annual series, of which this is No. 24.
In addition, although
the subtitle suggests the story ends in 1981, that year only marks
the end of ownership by what had become the D&RGW. Danneman brings
the story up to the present day and tells where ex-D&RGW equipment
still runs, for example at Knott's Berry Farm. Rosters of passenger
locomotives, cars, dining stations and express routes are included
in the appendices.Not surprisingly, most illustrations are in
black and white, but later ones are in color. Oddly, at least
in my purchased copy, pages 35 and 37 are identical, as are timetables
on pages 50 and 51. This error aside, I consider my money well
spent on this volume.
Reviewed by: R. G.
P.
Louisville & Nashville
Steam Locomotives
Authored by Richard
E. Prince - Indiana University Press, 601 North Morton Street,
Bloomington, Ind. 47404-3797.
Hardcover, 8-1/2"
x 11", 228 pp., 2001. $59.95.
This is another in
the series of reprints of books written by Mr. Prince on railroads
of the South during the steam era. These railroads have never
really been given the attention of those from the Northeast and
West. Thus, Mr. Prince's works have almost attained a cult status
among those interested in southern railroads. The book starts
with an history of the L&N, illustrated with maps from 1892 and
1932. An original locomotive roster appears with such interesting
facts as which ones were confiscated by the Confederate government
for use during the Civil War. This is followed by a chapter on
the expansion age from 1896 through 1929. We then get a chapter
on 20th Century steam locomotives. This includes a detailed roster
as well as information on their development and use, along with
a nice account of the M1 Class 2-8-4s, the road's only modern
'super-power' locomotives. It was interesting to learn that the
last four purchased were used primarily in Cincinnati-Corbin passenger
service on the Southland and the Flamingo. The locomotive section
is followed by very nice descriptions of the passenger and freight
services that the locomotives powered. This roughly covers the
period from 1859 through the late 1940s. An interesting tidbit
was that the heavy Florida Arrow was assigned Mountain-types between
Louisville and Montgomery, Ala. which were given auxiliary water
tenders with the train's name emblazoned on the side! Appropriate
timetables and entries from the Official Railway Guide appear
throughout the passenger service portion of the book.
Fortunately, freight
service is not neglected and we get coverage of it from 1928 thorough
the end of the steam era. Coal was a major source of traffic for
L&N Ñ in 1929, 58.6 percent of its traffic was coal. A good description
is given of what divisions originated coal and to what points
it was shipped. Scheduled manifest service is then covered along
with schedules of principal trains. The most famous fast freight
was the Silver Bullet on the Cincinnati to New Orleans mainline
for many years. Many locomotive and tonnage ratings are included
here and a nice touch is the listing of helper and doubleheading
districts for the year 1946.
A trademark of Mr.
Prince's works is a chapter on steamboat and port operations,
and this book is no exception. The L&N's main export commodities
were grain, coal and lumber. Several ships were owned by the line
and hauled Alabama coal as far away as Liverpool, England! A final
chapter covers the backshops and roundhouses. An interesting two-page
spread shows how a Class K4 Pacific was assembled in just five
days during World War I by the South Louisville shops. An appendix
contains a list of L&N locomotives and their construction numbers
from 1890 through 1944. There is also a list of engines acquired
by L&N from other roads and a list of final dispositions of all
L&N steamers.
I recommend this work
to all L&N and steam locomotive fans. It is nicely illustrated
and is a good history of L&N during the steam era. Although the
line disappeared as a corporation in 1982, it remains a key component
of the CSX Transportation system.
Reviewed by: Ray Cooney
JERSEY CENTRAL STEAM
IN COLOR
Authored by by Bert
Pennypacker - Morning Sun Books, Inc., 9 Pheasant Lane, Scotch
Plains, N.J., 07076.
Hardcover, 8-1/2"
x 11", 128 pp., 2000. $54.95 (plus $3.50 shipping).
Although the Central
of New Jersey kept steam locomotives in service relatively late,
the fact that at entire book of color photographs of CNJ steam
can be assembled is probably due to the fact the road was the
last to use camelbacks and was located in the populous Northeast.
Even though some special trains lead to heavier coverage than
might otherwise be deserved, there is a good variety of coverage
herein.The first half of the book is a look at the locomotives
themselves, class by class, although the views are far more than
just roster shots. The second half shows them along the railroad,
generally east to west, and ends with a tribute to the people
who ran the railroad. Photography is generally excellent, as expected
from this publisher, but there are exceptions, due to the rarity
of the scenes.
Captions are lengthy
and informative, but unfortunately not always correct. For example,
Pennypacker apparently was not aware of the track numbering scheme
the road used (odd east, even west). References to the Chemical
Coast, a definite anachronism, are found in a few places. The
CNJ had no Kearny Branch. A comment on a train on Page 34 having
two coaches (and therefore concluding what train it must be) is
incorrect; more cars are visible in the picture.These comments
do not detract from the rest of the knowledge and the irreplaceable
scenes to be found here. Steam fans, and certainly those of the
CNJ and the other "anthracite roads", will want to read this book.
Reviewed by: R. G.
P.
DELAWARE & HUDSON
STEAM IN COLOR
Authored by by Chuck
Yungkurth - Morning Sun Books, Inc., 9 Pheasant Lane, Scotch Plains,
N.J., 07076.
Hardcover, 8-1/2''
x 11", 128 pp., 2000. $54.95 (plus $3.50 shipping).
The Delaware & Hudson
is famous for steam locomotives with clean lines, as well as keeping
seemingly out-of-date types around later than other major roads;
the only exceptions besides the relatively late 4-8-4s and 4-6-6-4s
were Pacifics. Given that this book is all color, the only wheel
types seen here are those three plus Consolidations and Ten Wheelers.
The book is first arranged by locomotive type, then by various
locations on the railroad. The color photographs available meant
that the Pennsylvania Division was the site of most of the pictures
in this volume. Many of those pictures are helpers on the grades.
Despite the book's
name, there is more than just steam photography. Included are
several pictures of steam-era rolling stock (including cabooses
and the open-platform coaches used in the Scranton commuter trains),
coal breakers and other structures on the line (some taken in
modern times, though essentially unchanged since the steam era),
and diesel-hauled trains in the late steam era. Unfortunately,
many pictures are dark and their subjects are hard if not impossible
to discern. Less forgivable, however, is the incredibly sloppy
editing. President Leonor F. Loree, who dictated motive-power
policy for over three decades, has his first name misspelled Lenore.
His successor is referred to as both Nuelle and Novelle (the former
is correct). There are seven instances of incorrect locomotive
numbers in the captions, when the correct number is obvious in
the photo, and that doesn't count repeated use of the same wrong
number in the closing pages. Two captions cite information in
accompanying timetables to elaborate on the trains pictured, but
in both cases the timetables were not valid at the time of the
picture and incorrect information is imparted. Caveat emptor.
Reviewed by: R G. P.
TRACKSIDE ON THE
PRR NORTH OF WASHINGTON, D.C. WITH WAYNE SHERWIN
Authored by M.S. Murray,
OSFS and R.J. YanoseyMorning Sun Books, 9 Pheasant Lane, Scotch
Plains, N.J. 07076.
Hardcover, 8-1/2"
x 11", 128 pp., 2001. $54.95 (plus $3.50 shipping).
Wayne Sherwin worked
in train service for the Pennsylvania Railroad and other lines
for over 35 years and this latest all-color volume from Morning
Sun illustrates his interesting color photography. Much of it
was taken on the property while he was on duty. The brakeman started
in 1955 working on the Chesapeake Region and we mainly see shots
of trains running with steam, diesel and electric power along
the 'Corridor' from Washington, D.C. to North Jersey and then
on the Northern Central and the Enola/Harrisburg, Pa. area. There
are about 20 pages of photos west to Altoona, with Ohio and Chicago
in the rear of the book.Often, the photos are complemented with
reproductions of passes, tickets, timetables and brochures. I
enjoyed the perspective of scenes of trains, junctions and locations
photographed forward from the cab or from a side window of a locomotive.
There are a few scenes from the Penn Central days but they are
at least former PRR locations. Typically, Morning Sun runs a series
of shots (eight in this case at York Haven, Pa.) where probably
five at the most would do the job. The photos are really good
but another case of overkill. I also doubt that the eastbound
train on Horseshoe Curve (page 122) in the daylight is the Penn
Texas. There are other questionable captions that I will not pursue
here. Overall, the book has a much more positive value than me
quibbling about a few minor points and I think its content is
such that PRR fans will give it high marks.
Reviewed by: F. P.
K.
N de M in Color
Authored by Matthew
J. Herson Morning Sun Books, 9 Pheasant Lane, Scotch Plains, N.J.
07076.
Hardcover, 8-1/2"
x 11", 128 pp., 2000. $54.95 (plus $3.50 postage).
Although most fans
think of the United States when considering railroads, another
rail system very similar to those here exists south of the border.
In this latest offering from Morning Sun, Matthew Herson explores
the domain of the N de M (Ferrocarriles Nationales de Mexico)
and its component parts.The most striking characteristic of the
N de M was the amazing diversity of its roster, which, at one
time or another, seemed to list examples of most models ever made.
In this volume, Herson concentrates on the period from the 1960s
to the mid-1980s, beginning with the transition period between
steam and diesel. He begins with a concise history of the four
major components which, combined, made up the N de M, including
extensive narrow-gauge trackage. The Mexican government gradually
increased its influence, gaining complete control in 1937.
Most of the narrow-gauge
was converted to standard gauge, or abandoned, by 1947. After
the historical essay, the book is divided into four main sections:
Narrow Gauge; Steam, Diesel and Electric. Under each section,
the various types and models of locomotives are listed and illustrated.
Steam engines ranged from stubby 0-6-0 switchers to powerful 4-8-4s
(locally designated as 'Niagras'); Diesels include Alcos from
switchers to road-switchers to Century models; Baldwin Centipedes
and AS616s; EMD Fs, GPs, MPs, SDs and SWs; GE switchers, Us and
Cs; rebuilds, second-hand purchases, 'boomer' locomotives and
railcars; and the Alco-GE boxcab electrics.
While some of the photographs
are typical roster shots, the preponderance of them are lineside
shots of passenger and freight trains, handsomely reproduced.
Captions are informative and descriptive, although misplaced or
omitted commas sometimes make reading difficult. Maps and graphics
add more detail. All told, this is an interesting look at the
motive power of N de M and its operations. Fans and modelers alike
will enjoy it.
Reviewed by: J.N.J.H.
Dutch Country Trolleys
Authored by Frederick
A. Kramer - Railroad Avenue Enterprises, P.O. Box l14, Flanders,
N.J. 07836-0114
Softcover, 8 1/2"
x 11", 64pp., 2000. $15.95(plus $2.00 shipping).
South central Pennsylvania
was once the home of several trolley systems, two of which are
featured here: the Conestoga Traction Company of Lancaster and
the Hershey Transit Company of the chocolate city. Each is given
equal attention in this attractive pictorial study by veteran
Author Frederick Kramer.Conestoga's lines radiated from Lancaster
like a spider's web to such towns as Manheim, Lititz, Ephrata,
Blue Ball, Strasburg, Columbia and Quarryville, and connected
with cars to more distant points including Harrisburg, Reading
and Philadelphia. As with most electric railways, decline began
in the 1920s and accelerated during the Depression years, when
a massive bus conversion program was initiated. By World War II
only some city routes, served by a fleet of Birneys, and the line
to Ephrata remained. The last car ran in 1947.
Hershey Transit was
the work of Milton Hershey, who established his namesake town
in Dauphin County early in the century. To serve his chocolate
factory, the town and the boys at the Hershey Industrial School,
Hershey built lines to Hummelstown, Palmyra, Lebanon and Elizabethtown,
and a short line to serve his spectacular new hotel. In addition
to people, the lines also carried untold quantities of milk from
area farms to the chocolate factory. Operations began during the
early part of the century and continued until 1946 shortly after
Hershey's death.
In addition to the
brief historical backgrounds, each half of the book contains a
selection of well-reproduced photographs of the cars and the areas
they served. The pictures are arranged according to the separate
lines, and they include freight and work equipment as well as
the passenger cars. Short captions provide additional information.
Maps and graphics are included. As is common in books dealing
with long-gone companies, a number of errors have crept into the
book. To his great credit, however, and with the help of Fred
W. Schneider III, Kramer has prepared an errata list, which is
sent with the book, detailing the errors and providing additional
information. Other authors would do well to follow this example.The
book is a pleasant look at a vanished world and is well worth
the price. Trolley fans will enjoy it.
Reviewed by: J.N.J.H.
THE LAKESIDE AND
MARBLEHEAD RAILROAD
Authored by Dean K.
Fick - Montevallo Historical Press, Inc., 5810 West Bogart Road,
Castalia, Ohio 44824.
Hardcover, 8 1/2"
x 11", 176 pp. 2000. $39.95 (plus $6.00 shipping).
Marblehead Peninsula
is a body of land in Ohio roughly 22 miles long, which extends
into Lake Erie parallel to the coast. The eastern end of the peninsula
is across Sandusky Bay from the city of the same name. The former
New York Central Railroad (later Penn Central, Conrail and now
Norfolk Southern) crosses the bay at the town of Danbury en route
from Cleveland to Toledo. Danbury was the junction with the Lakeside
& Marblehead, which extended less than eight miles to the two
towns in the road's name. Opened in 1887, it last operated in
1978 and was torn up in 1997.The raison d'etre of the road was
to service the limestone quarrying business, which early in its
history became dominated by the Kelley Island Lime and Transport
Company, which operated several quarries (and other operations
related to quarrying, such as crushers) in the general area. (The
company's name comes from Kelley Island, not far away from the
peninsula in Lake Erie.) For several years, part of its line was
electrified to handle trains of the interurban Toledo, Port Clinton
& Lakeside (the subject of an earlier book, recently reprinted
by this publisher).
The book is an excellent
history of the line, well written and easily read, with appropriate
pictures (the amount of material that survived on this relatively
unknown line is a true benefit) and many detailed maps inserted
at proper places in the text as changes and construction are described.
In fact, the only complaint this reviewer has is that there is
no good overall map of the line that shows the relative location
of all the changes over time. The story is told chronologically,
and is supplanted by 42 pages of appendices, bibliography and
index. The appendices detail all the locomotives owned by the
road, and include a listing of the many narrow-gauge engines operated
by the mining company (not the railroad) that are mentioned in
the text, but not covered in detail. Rolling stock is also enumerated,
including maintenance of way equipment, as are selected payroll
records, freight shipment statistics, profile map and a variety
of railroad documents.Mr. Fick is to be congratulated for his
thorough coverage of this line; future books by this author would
be welcome. Fans of Ohio railroads, shortlines or rail history
will want a copy.
Reviewed by: R.G.P.
NORFOLK AND WESTERNPASSENGER
SERVICE 1946-1971
Authored by William
E. Warden and Revised by Kenneth L. Miller - TLC Publishing, 1387
Winding Creek Lane, Lynchburg, Va. 24503-3776.
Hardcover, 8-1/2" x
11", 136 pp., 2000. $28.95 (plus $4.00 shipping and handling).
This book is a corrected
and expanded edition of a 1990 publication, whose title is descriptive.
Except for a new final chapter of 16 pages, the photographs are
black and white. Although the years of coverage extend through
1971, the only passenger trains discussed are those that ran on
what comprised the N&W prior to merger with the Wabash and Nickel
Plate (save for one picture in the color section); since passenger
service on the former Virginian was gone by the time of its merger
into the N&W, that service is not included.Organization is mostly
by train: chapter subjects are the Powhatan Arrow, Pocahontas,
Cavalier, Tennesseean, Pelican and Birmingham Special, Cannonball,
the trains on the branch to Hagerstown, branchline and local trains,
stations and color photographs. Pictures that cover the train
throughout its lifetime accompany each chapter. The front endsheet
contains a detailed system map from the 1930s that is useful for
locating sites mentioned in the text. A few timetables and other
memorabilia are depicted, but except for the chapter on stations,
we see the trains themselves or their power. The text notes most
of the changes that took place during the lifetimes of the trains,
but dates are usually given by year or we are told that the service
changes were in effect by a certain date; historians find few
exact dates in this volume. Detailed consists are not included.
Text is quite readable.For fans of the N&W and those interested
in passenger trains during the end of their era, this volume is
useful. It is only marginally helpful as a historical treatise.
Reviewed by: R. G.
P.
CHICAGO & EASTERN
ILLINOIS RAILROAD IN COLOR
Authored by Edward
M. DeRouin - Morning Sun Books, Inc., 9 Pheasant Lane, Scotch
Plains, N.J., 07076.
Hardcover, 8 1/2"
x 11", 128 pp. 2001. $54.95 (plus $3.50 shipping).
Before the railroad
was taken over by Missouri Pacific, then carved up between MP
and Louisville & Nashville, C&EI was best known for carrying southern
Illinois coal and for being the Chicago access for L&N's Georgian
and Hummingbird (and before that, the route of the 'Dixie' trainsÑDixie
Flagler, Dixie Flyer, Dixieland and others). This book is an overall
look at the short regional carrier whose three prongs south from
Chicago reached Evansville, Ind., the Illinois coal fields and
St. Louis (via trackage rights over New York Central). Although
most of the book is dedicated to trains and scenes along the railroad
(particularly heavy in the Chicago area, scarce in the coal fields),
chapters treat the diesel roster, passenger equipment and freight
and non-revenue cars. Since an all-color book is naturally limited
to the color film era, coverage is quite sparse before the '60s.
Since the road dieselized by 1949, there are but three pictures
of C&EI steam, and pictures of passenger trains before the '60s
are few. While E and F units are common subjects, the attractive
blue and orange paint scheme is not. Though balance of coverage
is dependent upon color availability, after a while the standard
three-quarter shots of freights and the combined Georgian/Hummingbird
or Danville Flyer on the straight route south of Chicago seem
somewhat overdone. Bonuses include detours, special trains, the
road's BL1 and BL2s in action, St. Louis activity (rarely seen),
and pictures of a number of paper items. A minor quibble: the
author or editor should have caught the consistent misspellings
of 'principal' (misspelled 'principle') and 'Steger' (a Chicago-area
passenger station).
Reviewed by: R.G.P.
CENTRAL VERMONT
IN COLOR
Authored by George
F. Melvin and Jeremy F. Plant - Morning Sun Books, 9 Pheasant
Lane, Scotch Plains, N.J. 07076.
Hardcover, 8-1/2" x
11", 128 pp., 2000. $54.95 (plus $3.50 shipping).
The Central Vermont
Railway had its origins in the 1840s and 1850s with the Vermont
Central, Vermont & Canada and other small predecessor lines. Trustees
ran the V&C until 1873 when the CV Railroad was formed. The Canadian
National through its Grand Trunk Railway subsidiary took control
of the company in the 1890s. The CV's mainline ran from New London,
Conn. to the Vermont-Quebec border with a handful of branchlines
that added up to about 400 miles of railroad. After the Great
Vermont Flood of 1927 it went bankrupt and was reorganized in
1930 as the CV Railway. This road ran an interesting and distinct
operation through mostly rural New England and the Green Mountains
"Norman Rockwell country"that was a favorite among railfans.
Many remember its well-known passenger trains Montrealer, Washingtonian
and Ambassador. These were not hotshot streamliners but comfortable
and friendly varnish that were gone by 1966. Later, in 1972, CV
began operating another Montrealer for Amtrak. In 1994 the line
was sold to RailTex (now RailAmerica) and the new owner called
the road the New England Central, which operates almost 100 percent
of the old CV.There is a brief history of the railroad, its geography,
operations and motive power.
Also included is a
diesel and a "modern" steam locomotive roster (Nos. 218 through
709) that is helpful. I was going to mention some of my favorite
color shots, but as I progressed through the book I realized that
this review would just go on and on as there are so many wonderful
scenes depicted. In my estimation, this so far is the best of
the "In Color" publications that Morning Sun has delivered. The
authors and the over 35 photographers that contributed to the
book can be proud. I would like to mention the following lens
experts whose work represents about a third of all the excellent
photos shown: Dave Bartlett, Art Mitchell, Ben Crouch, Bob Sheridan,
George Melvin, Ralph Phillips, Donald Robinson and John Gardner.
If the reader has any interest in the CV, then this is a "must
get" book.
Reviewed by: F.P.K.