If Diesel Could See His Dream Now!
by
Hank Morris
Imagine an engine,
first developed in 1895, that was so good that examples from this
era still work perfectly today. An engine first designed to run
on gunpowder then developed to use vegetable oil injected under
pressure directly into the combustion chamber. An engine that
needed no spark or electricity to run and that is still the only
choice for heavy transport to this day. This engine is of course
the Diesel engine.
Though best known
for his invention of the pressure-ignited heat engine that bears
his name, the French-born Rudolf Diesel (March 18, 1858 - September
29, 1913) (shown in picture at right) was also an eminent thermal
engineer, a connoisseur of the arts, a linguist, and a social
theorist. Diesel's inventions have three points in common: They
relate to heat transference by natural physical processes or
laws; they involve markedly creative mechanical design; and
they were initially motivated by the inventor's concept of sociological
needs.
Born in Paris, Diesel
was the son of a leather merchant. He studied at Munich Polytechnic
where he was a sort of renaissance man. Arts, linguistics and
social theories then in development all held him in a spell.
One day Diesel saw
something strange: A pneumatic cigarette lighter. Small pieces
of tinder are in a little glass tube. With a piston, air is
compressed in the tube and the tinder starts to glow. This vision
set him afire.
He set up a laboratory
in Paris in 1885, and took out his first patent in 1892. In
August 1893 he went to Augsburg, Germany, where he showed the
forerunner of MAN AG (Maschinenfabrik Augsburg-Nuerenberg) a
three-meter-long iron cylinder with a piston driving a flywheel.
It was an economic thermodynamic engine to replace the steam
engine. Diesel called it an atmospheric gas engine, but the
name didn't stick.
He worked on. On
New Year's Eve 1896 and proudly displayed an engine that had
a theoretical efficiency of 75.6 percent. Of course, this theoretical
efficiency could not be attained, but there was nothing to equal
it—and there is nothing to equal it to this day—in thermodynamic
engines.
The self-igniting
engine was a sensation of the outgoing century, though Rudolf
Diesel's dream of enabling the small craftsmen to withstand
the power of big industry did not ripen. Instead, big industry
quickly took up his idea, and Diesel became very rich with his
royalties.
Rudolf Diesel did
not build the machine that bears his name. Rather he developed
a theory of internal combustion, plus a few crude prototypes.
However, none of the prototypes he worked on in his lifetime,
worked especially well.
Diesel originally conceived
the diesel engine as a facility, readily adaptable in size and
costs and using locally available fuels, to enable independent
craftsmen and artisans better to endure the powered competition
of large industries that then virtually monopolized the predominant
power source-the oversized, expensive, fuel-wasting steam engine.
In 1893, German inventor
Rudolph Diesel published a paper entitled “The Theory and Construction
of a Rational Heat Engine,” which described an engine in which
air is compressed by a piston to a very high pressure, causing
a high temperature. Fuel is then injected and ignited by the
compression temperature.
How is a diesel different
from a spark ignition engine? In a spark ignition engine, air
and fuel (gasoline) are mixed in the combustion chamber, compressed,
and then ignited with a spark from the spark plug. In a diesel
engine, air is compressed first, and then fuel is injected under
very high pressures into the hot compressed air where it ignites
immediately. For a number of reasons, particularly the much
higher compression ratio, this is a more efficient way to get
work output from the fuel. And because of the high pressures
and forces which take place within the engine, diesels must
be built much more robustly, which helps makes diesels last
longer. So, most of the applications where diesels are applied
are those in which fuel economy and long life are important
to cost competitiveness in delivery of goods.
A spark combustion
engine uses a throttle to control the amount of air coming into
the engine, thus the amount of power that the engine will produce.
There is no throttle in the diesel engine, thus there are no
“pumping” losses as found in a spark ignition engine which struggles
to suck air past a partially closed throttle at lower engine
loads. Thus, when idling, a diesel engine uses perhaps only
one fourth as much fuel as a spark ignition engine (that’s why
you shouldn’t worry when you see a locomotive sitting with its
engine running all night.)
Rudolph Diesel initially
considered powdered coal and, later on, liquid fuels such as
vegetable oil and petroleum as possible fuels. Powdered coal
proved difficult to inject into the engine cylinder and eventually
caused an explosion that destroyed the prototype engine. He
built his first engine based on that theory the same year and,
though it worked only sporadically, he patented it. Within a
few years, his design became the standard of the world for that
type of engine and his name was attached to it.
No other engine inventor's
name is as closely tied to his engine as Rudolph Diesel's is.
But Diesel worked hard to make it that way. Historian Linwood
Bryant tells us that Diesel saw himself as a scientific genius
and the James Watt of the late 19th century. He was vain, oversensitive,
and not a little paranoid. He didn't win the hearts of other
engine makers.
At Augsburg, on August
10, 1893, Diesel's prime model, a single 10-foot iron cylinder
with a flywheel at its base, ran on its own power for the first
time. During 1885 Diesel set up his first shop-laboratory in
Paris and began his 13-year ordeal of creating his distinctive
engine. Diesel spent two more years at improvements and on the
last day of 1896 demonstrated another model with the spectacular,
if theoretical, mechanical efficiency of 75.6 percent, in contrast
to the then-prevailing efficiency of the steam engine of 10
percent or less.
Diesel built the
first diesel engine in 1897 at the Augsburg Maschinenfabrik
(now known as MAN). The single-cylinder engine was used to power
stationary machinery. It weighed 4.4 tons (five tonnes) and
produced 20 hp at 172 rpm. The engine operated at 26.2 percent
efficiency, a very significant improvement on the 20 percent
achieved by the best gasoline engines of the time. A number
of industrialists expressed interest in acquiring licenses.
Although commercial
manufacture begun at a snail's pace, by 1898 Diesel was a millionaire
from franchise fees in great part international.
In March 1898, Scientific American published: “An advance
as important as the introduction of the internal combustion
motor has been made by Dr. Rudolph Diesel, of Munich. The experiments
which led to the construction of the present successful machine
began in 1882. In the ordinary gas or oil engine, the charge
within the cylinder is ignited by a jet, hot tube or electric
spark. In the Diesel motor the temperature of ignition is secured
by the compression of pure air. Air is compressed to a pressure
of up to 600 pounds to the square inch and the fuel, kerosene,
is injected gradually into the cylinder and is burnt steadily
during the stroke of the piston.”
Diesel
thought that the United States was the greatest potential market
for his engine. The first diesel built in the United States
was made in 1898 by Busch-Zulzer Brothers Diesel Engine Co.
The president of that company was Adolphus Busch, of Budweiser
brewing fame, who had purchased North American manufacturing
rights. Busch-Sulzer concentrated on stationary and marine Diesels.
Many of its engines were installed in oceangoing ships and also
large ferry boats. Another big market for Busch-Sulzer Diesels
was the public utility field. Many municipalities, the country
over generated electricity with Busch-Sulzer engines.
Upon conclusion
of World War II, the company and its properties and good will
were acquired by the Nordborg Manufacturing Company of Milwaukee,
Wis. The Nordberg company was an old, established manufacturer
of Diesels and worthy in every respect of carrying on the
Busch-Sulzer traditions.
When Dr. Rudolph
Diesel demonstrated his engine at the world exhibition in Paris
in 1900 he said two words that astonished the gathered engineers
“peanut oil” The patented diesel engine ran on almost any fuel
from petrol to vegetable oil! The engine was demonstrated at
this exhibition running perfectly on straight peanut oil. Unfortunately
Dr Diesel died before his vision of a vegetable oil powered
engine was fully realized.
The seeds of the
dispute, Bryant argues, were sown in Diesel's view of invention—the
usual view that a device is first invented, then developed,
and finally improved. Diesel left very clear records of what
he actually did. There's no doubt that between 1890 and '93
he invented the engine using his knowledge of thermodynamics.
The idea of burning fuel slowly, and at higher pressures, was
certainly his.
There's also no doubt
that he worked from 1893 to '97 at the Augsburg Machine-Works
to develop a working engine. During this time Diesel faced problem
after problem. To solve them he had to do a lot more theoretical
work and more invention. In Diesel's view, he was still inventing
the engine. People outside the process saw all this as development—the
dirty work that anyone has to go through to make a good idea
into workable hardware.
After 1897 Diesel
figured he was done with his invention, and he turned to promoting
it. But the engine was woefully unready for the market. Eleven
more years of improvement and innovation were needed. Meanwhile,
Diesel worked himself into a nervous breakdown promoting the
not-yet-ready engine.
Diesel died under
mysterious circumstances on September 29, 1913, vanishing during
an overnight crossing of the English Channel on the mail steamer
Dresden from Antwerp, Belgium to Harwich, Essex, England. His floating
body was found ten days later.
Having already convinced
the French navy that the only choice for submarine power was
his engine and its associated low risk and edible fuel he was
on his way to England by boat to try to do the same for the
English navy when he disappeared.
Diesel's death might
have been suicide, accidental, or an assassination.
When his body was
found adrift in the English Channel a few days later, the English
newspapers at the time suggested that French operatives trying
to keep his engine out of the English submarine fleet had assassinated
him. Other proponents of the assassination theory point out
that shortly after Diesel's death, a diesel-powered German submarine
fleet became the scourge of the seas.
Proponents of the
suicide theory point to the fact that he was quite upset by
criticisms of his work by other machinery manufacturers. In
1912, 20 years after the engine was conceived, four books were
written about its development. Diesel wrote one. The other three
were by people who were out to minimize his claims. He had irritated
other engine designers by sneering at their work. In 1897, after
he announced he had finished construction of the first commercially
successful motor, he arrogantly asserted that few factories
were good enough to build his engines—that second-string makers
shouldn't even try. He failed to see that what made his engine
viable in the marketplace was a lot of truly inventive thinking
by a lot of good engineers. All Diesel's concern over public
opinion made him an unhappy person. A person with that kind
of talent should've known how to sit back and enjoy it.
The “whats” and “whys”
of his demise will never be known, let alone the “whos”.
After Dr. Diesel's
death the petroleum industry capitalized on his engine by labeling
a by-product of petrol manufacture “diesel fuel” and modifying
his engine to run on it. Diesel fuel was an invention that came
much later than the diesel engine. Clean renewable vegetable
oil was all but forgotten as a source of power.
A consortium of
Alco, General Electric, and Ingersoll-Rand (AGEIR) first produced
the 8835 (shown at left) demonstrator diesel-electric locomotive.
Early into the demonstration trials it became apparent that
the economic gains, reliability, and timing of prototype #8835
combined to create an acceptance of the Diesel-electric as
a practical means of motive power. Demonstration service began
June 9, 1924 with the New York Central RR in its West Side
Yards and were concluded at the Alan Wood Steel Company of
Conshohocken, Penn. on July 11, 1925. The success of these
demonstrations prompted General Electric to design two versions
of a Diesel-electric locomotive that would be entered into
production. A 60-ton using one 300 hp Ingersoll-Rand engine
and a 100-ton unit rated at 600 hp derived from two Ingersoll-Rand
diesel power plants.
In
June, 1925, the first production American-made diesel-electric
locomotive—a 60-ton 300-hp Box Cab unit built on Alco Order
No. S1484 and was assigned Alco builders plate No. 65979 and
GE builders plate No. 9681 (shown right) . In keeping with General
Electric's practice its builders plate No. 9681 was assigned
to this unit while it was used in demonstrations at the Ingersoll-Rand
plant in Phillipsburg, N.J. Number 9681 was completed and operating
on the East Erie Test Track. It was delivered to Ingersoll-Rand
under its own power during July 1925 where it replaced prototype
No. 8835 as an in-house demonstrator. No. 8835 was retained
for a short while as an interplant switch engine before being
retired.
The construction
of diesel-electric locomotives began with Alco issuing a Stock
Order for the manufacture of one or more units of the same type.
The “S” in AGEIR Order Numbers indicated that the mechanical
portions were scheduled to be fabricated at Alco's Schenectady,
N.Y. plant. Each completed assembly was then given an Alco builders
number and shipped to General Electric's Erie, Penn. works where
the Ingersoll-Rand diesel engines were being received. General
Electric also issued a builders number for each of the units
they were completing and Builders Plates were ordered for each
locomotive and inscribed with both of the builders numbers as
well as the names of each company of this consortium and general
construction dates.
The Ingersoll-Rand
four-cycle, vertical, six-cylinder diesel power plant with a
10” bore and a 12” stroke was rated at 600 rpm (550?) and 300
hp. Fuel was direct injected using a rotating distributing valve
(something that Ingersoll-Rand was very proud of as the parts
were machined to such close tolerances that they had to be lubricated
prior to assembly). Lubrication was force-fed with the pressure
pump and filter located in the crank case (an external distribution
valve with dirt collector and fuel oil filter was also employed).
The engine was of a water jacket design, including the head,
and the water was cooled on the first eight 60-ton units by
two roof-mounted fin tube convection type radiators with a total
of 1,200 sq.ft. surface. The temperature was controlled by a
thermostat and by-pass.
The generator for
the three 60-ton units built on Alco Order No. S1484 was a General
Electric 200 kW model TD-502 rated at 600 V and direct-connected
to the engine. In turn a six kW, 60-V auxiliary generator (exciter)
was direct connected. The shunt windings were separately excited
and the series winding was differential compound. Voltage variation
was rated at 200-750 V.
Beginning with Alco
Order No. S1532, an improved General Electric Model T-D-6-6-200
Generator rated at 600 volts was used. Four General Electric
Model HM-840 traction motors were installed (until Alco Order
No. S1543, when Model GE292H motors were used). They had a nominal
rating of 95 hp each at 600 V with two connected in parallel
on each truck with series and parallel groupings.
Control of the early
300 hp locomotives was implemented by Model 2-C-173-A (Lemp
system) controllers with electro-magnetic contactors and a reverser
(one set of motorman controls located at each end of these AGEIR
Box Cab units). A Type CP-26-600-V or Model CP-24-A12-600 compressor
supplied 90 - 140 psi of pressure for the air brakes. One mechanically
driven and/or one gasoline powered Mianus compressor furnished
air for starting the diesel oil engine (Until Ingersoll-Rand
locomotive No. 90 - Alco Builders No. 66752 - GE Builders No.
10132. At this time recharged storage batteries in conjunction
with additional windings on the main generator cranked the power
plant for starting).
Demonstrations of
AGEIR 60-ton, 300 hp, No. 9681 were conducted in switching service
at the Phillipsburg plant of Ingersoll-Rand beginning in July
1925. The CNJ Railroad had been one of the rail operations to
participate in the earlier No. 8835 prototype demonstrator program
and when they sent representatives to evaluate No. 9681 they
were suitably impressed. The cab design was to their liking
and the bulkheads separating the operator areas from the more
centrally located main diesel engine section were amongst other
improvements noted over the prototype. They purchased the unit
and became the first owners of a production diesel-electric
locomotive. No. 9681 retained its ALCO and GE builders numbers
and the unit was painted “gloss black,” relettered (in “gold
Gothic”) No. 1000 for the Central R.R. of New Jersey and delivered
under its own power to the CNJ shops at Elizabeth Port, N.J.
Car floats were a common practice in the New York City area
and CNJ No. 1000 was delivered from Jersey City to the Bronx
Terminal Yard by this means. No. 1000 entered service there
on October 22, 1925 and spent its entire career of over three
decades at this location. This unit was classified CNJ SD-3
and D3-O at various times. According to an account by N.W. James,
a CNJ Director of Publicity, this AGEIR locomotive was overhauled
and repainted with a “deep Sea Green” and the Jersey Central
Lines “Miss Liberty” logo and lettering applied in “yellow”
during 1947. In 1957 this historic Box Cab locomotive was retired
and went on display at the Baltimore & Ohio Railroad Museum
located in Baltimore, Md.
Today, there are
two major locomotive manufacturers in the U.S., EMD and GE.
The top of the line EMD is the SD90MAC and the top of the line
GE is the AC6000. The SD90MAC uses the GM16V265H 16-cylinder,
6,300 hp engine. It measures 15 ft 8 in high by 80 ft 2 in long
by 10 ft. 3 in. and weighs 415,000 lb. It produces 200,000 lbf
starting tractive effort. The AC6000 (pictured below) uses GE’s
GE7HDL 16-cylinder, 6,250 hp engine. It measures 15 ft 3 in
high by 76 ft long and 9 ft. 11 in wide and weighs 425,000 lb.
It also produces 200,000 lbf starting tractive effort.
NOTE: The
Author is the editor of the National Railway Bulletin, the NRHS'
premiere publication.
